Renewal season is open. Groups with a January anniversary should start now — book a renewal review.

Independent and multi-carrier. Licensed in 11 states. No cost to you.

Choose your view: employer or individual
TTY 711(614) 555-0242

Independent and multi-carrier

The panel, and how we shop it

We hold appointments across the market and are captive to none of it. Nobody pays us more for placing you with one company over another, which is the only reason a comparison is worth anything.

Carriers on the panel
18
Captive contracts
None
Cost to you
$0
Set of comfortable orange armchairs placed around long white table in modern workspace with TV on wall and glass door

The panel

Every carrier we can put in front of you

Eighteen companies across nine lines, and a contract with none of them.

  • Alderway HealthGroup medical, individual medical
  • Northreach MutualGroup medical, life, disability
  • Vireon Health PlansMedicare Advantage, Part D
  • Steadhaven LifeTerm, permanent and group life
  • Quillon DentalGroup and individual dental
  • Brookfern VisionGroup and individual vision
  • Harborlight Benefit Co.Level-funded medical, stop loss
  • Cresswell MutualMedicare Supplement, life
  • Tallgrass Health AllianceRegional HMO and EPO
  • Orrindale AssuranceCritical illness, accident, hospital
  • Wrenfield Dental & VisionBundled ancillary
  • Lumenbrook SupplementalGap, indemnity, disability
  • Fairmount Health GroupGroup medical, level-funded
  • Silverbeck AssuranceGroup life and disability
  • Elmgate VisionGroup and individual vision
  • Pinegrove DentalGroup and individual dental
  • Ravenwood MutualMedicare Advantage, Part D
  • Castellon Health PartnersMulti-state PPO medical

Network footprint

The cheapest carrier may not reach your people

Regional carriers price aggressively at home because their networks are tight there. That is a genuine bargain for a workforce inside one county and a bad trade the moment somebody lives across a state line.

Black compass on detailed map symbolizing navigation and exploration.

What the four network shapes actually do

Network structures compared. Plan rules vary by carrier and county.
TypeReferralsOut of networkGeographySuitsCost posture
HMOPrimary care referral usually requiredEmergency onlyTightest. Often a single metro or a named hospital systemA workforce that lives and works in one countyLowest premium on a matched benefit design
EPONo referral requiredEmergency onlyRegional. Wider than HMO, still no out-of-area routine careOne metro plus surrounding counties, little travelSlightly above HMO
POSReferral required for the in-network tierCovered at a higher cost shareRegional core with a national wrapMostly local staff with occasional out-of-area needMid-range
PPONoneCovered at a higher cost shareBroadest. National networks are commonDistributed or travelling workforces, and dependents at college out of stateHighest premium of the four
Tiered or narrowVariesUsually emergency onlyA curated subset of a broader networkEmployers willing to trade choice for a double-digit premium reductionBelow HMO, with the narrowest provider list

Scroll the table sideways to see every column.

Footprint by carrier shape

National PPO carriers

Lines
Group medical, dental, vision, life
Footprint
All 50 states, broadest provider counts
Network shape
Broad PPO with regional HMO options

The default answer for a workforce spread across more than two states. You pay for the breadth whether or not you use it.

Ohio regional carriers

Lines
Group medical, Medicare Advantage
Footprint
Ohio and contiguous counties
Network shape
Strong local HMO and EPO, thin outside the region

Frequently the best price in Franklin, Delaware and Licking counties. Becomes a problem the moment you hire in Texas.

Health-system-owned plans

Lines
Group medical, Medicare Advantage
Footprint
One metro, anchored to the owning system
Network shape
Narrow, system-aligned

Aggressive pricing if your staff already use that system. Very little to offer someone who does not.

Ancillary specialists

Lines
Dental, vision, life, disability, supplemental
Footprint
National, independent of the medical network
Network shape
Own PPO networks, separate from medical

Dental and vision networks do not follow the medical carrier. They are checked separately, every time.

Four gaps we find most often

  • The county line

    Rating areas and network contracts both stop at county boundaries. An employee who moves from Franklin County to a rural county twenty minutes away can lose in-network access to the hospital they have always used.

  • The out-of-state dependent

    A child at university in another state is the most common gap we find. HMO and EPO plans cover them for emergencies only, which is fine until a chronic condition needs managing.

  • The remote hire

    Hiring one developer in another state can push an entire group off a regional carrier, or leave that one person with emergency-only coverage. Check the network before the offer letter, not after.

  • The snowbird retiree

    Medicare Advantage networks are county-based. Three months in Florida each winter is a genuine reason to look at a Medicare Supplement instead, which has no network at all.

Provider directories change continuously. Check per plan, per county and per provider before enrolling.

Method

How a market shop actually runs

Six steps, the same every time, whether the group has six lives or two hundred and sixty.

  1. Match the design first

    We rebuild your current benefit design across every carrier before comparing price, so you are looking at the same plan rather than a cheaper one.

  2. Then two alternates

    One richer, one leaner, each priced on the same census. Most employers end up choosing one of these rather than the match.

  3. Check the networks

    Every carrier on the shortlist is checked against where your people actually live, not against your office address.

  4. Check the ancillary separately

    Dental and vision networks do not follow the medical carrier. They are verified on their own provider lists.

  5. Show the working

    You get the comparison as a document you keep, including the options we did not recommend and why.

  6. Go back to the incumbent

    A market shop frequently ends with a renegotiated renewal where you already are. Knowing the market is what makes that conversation work.

Send the census. We will run the panel.

A first-pass comparison usually comes back in two to four business days, and it costs you nothing either way.

Independent and multi-carrier. $0 cost to work with us. No pressure scripts.

Cookie preferences

Choose which cookies you allow. You can change this at any time from the link in the footer.